Forever Sweetened LLC can ONLY accept payment for shipments, deliveries, and/or drop points within New Mexico due to cottage food laws.
〰️
Forever Sweetened LLC can ONLY accept payment for shipments, deliveries, and/or drop points within New Mexico due to cottage food laws. 〰️
Discover Joy in Every Bite
Welcome to my sweet swirl of deliciousness, where every bite is a delightful adventure! My baked goods are homemade, will tickle your taste buds, and brighten your day with sugary smiles and flaky fun.
Featured Products
Indulge in this irresistible Treat Boxes — a trio of crowd-pleasing favorites baked to buttery, gooey perfection. Each box includes:
Two ooey-gooey Cookies with crisp edges and melty chocolate pockets
Two flavor packed, nutty Brown Butter Brownies with a crackly top and a fudgy center
Two Brown Butter Vanilla Rice Crispy Treats: light, pillowy, and infused with rich brown butter, vanilla, and chocolate.
Why choose just one when you can savor all three? Perfect for gifting, celebrations, or a decadent treat-yourself moment.
Pre-orders open at the start of each week and close when quantities are reached or the deadline passes. Orders placed Monday–Thursday ship the following Monday. Orders placed after Thursday will ship with the next week’s batch.
For custom boxes (i.e., Birthdays, Anniversaries, Graduations, etc.), or individual items by the dozen please email foreversweetened@gmail.com
These homemade cookies deliver the perfect harmony of rich chocolate, buttery cookie dough, and layered sweet flavors—irresistible from the first bite. At 3 ounces each, they’re generously sized and impossible to stop at one. Enjoy them with a cold glass of milk, a steaming cup of coffee, or hot cocoa—or savor them all on their own. Perfect for any occasion, any time of year.
Verity box includes six (6) cookies, one (1) of each flavor.
Pre-orders take place at the beginning of each week until the limit has been reached or the deadline has been met. Orders placed Monday-Thursday will be shipped on Monday the following week. Orders placed after Thursday will be shipped with the following weeks orders.
For custom boxes (i.e., Birthdays, Anniversaries, Graduations, etc.) please email foreversweetened@gmail.com
A New Mexican crisp butter cookie flavored with sugar and cinnamon, and are traditionally made during holidays, special occasions, and just because. Enjoy these delicious cookies year round.
Great for any occasion!
Pre-orders take place at the beginning of each week until the limit has been reached or the deadline has been met. Orders placed Monday-Thursday will be shipped on Monday the following week. Orders placed after Thursday will be shipped with the following weeks orders.
For custom boxes (i.e., Birthdays, Anniversaries, Graduations, etc.) please email foreversweetened@gmail.com
Forever Sweetened LLC is a home-based bakery inspired by sugary smiles. As someone who loves to bake, I've always found baking to be an outlet for escaping the sadness of the world, and an opportunity to help add a little bit of happiness back into it. Seeing family, friends, and even strangers light up as they dig into my sweet treats is pure magic. When those first bites of deliciousness brighten someone's day, it makes everything worthwhile. With over a decade of experience baking for loved ones, I'm thrilled to now share my passion with the community through Forever Sweetened. Take the leap of faith with me as I follow my heart and do what I love - baking up joy one sweet treat at a time. Let Forever Sweetened satisfy that sweet tooth while brightening up your day!
Get to
know me
Follow me on social
Contact Me & Special Order Request
For custom orders, or inquiries fill out some info and I’ll be in touch shortly. I can’t wait to hear from you!